Yankee Tavern

You're not likely to run into greats like Babe Ruth or Yogi Berra anymore—we never did get around to adding a "Ghost Bar" category, after all—but this bar has remained as holy an altar to the Yankees as it was in 1923 when it opened. Necessarily, the walls are bedecked with paraphernalia heralding the home team and stays open late on game nights, whether home or away. To even things out—not that Jeter is going to come in and buy a round like the Babe—a pretty impressive menu of Italian food and some surprisingly good seafood is available.